Refine Search
Map
Sort by
2771 Teal Court, St James City
$1,533,333
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
This home has it all. It sits on a gorgeous interior bay with big views. You can safely keep your boats behind your house. It has a large dock with space for four boats with two boat lifts. There is a large backyard with a pool and spa with a paver patio. Below the home is a large carport for your cars and toys, plus almost 2300 square feet of storage, workshop, craft room, or whatever. Take a look at the interior photos. There is too much to mention, but some of the highlights are a completely remodeled modern kitchen with granite countertops, two islands, and all new appliances, a separate living room and family room, a pass-through fireplace between the family room and primary bedroom, large primary bath with dual sinks and separate tub and shower, home office/library, all paver driveway and patios, huge porches front and rear (sunset views), and much more. The photos do a much better job of describing this home than anyone can. Here are more details: new kitchen-2017; new pool and pool deck-2021; new seawall-2020; replace front porch decking and railing-2018; replace back porch decking and railing-2019; new metal roof-2021; resod backyard-2021; redo guest bathroom tile, counter and cabinets-2020; new recessed lighting-2019; new solar fans in attic-2018; new office cabinets and countertop-2020; new electric at dock-2021; new hurricane windows, front of house-2018; new gutters-2017&2021; new fence-2021; new primary bathroom cabinets, lights, vanity counter, and shower door-2021-2022; new carpet-2022; new hurricane sliders-2023; new floor in sewing room-2023; new shelving in sewing room-2023; new front gutters-2023; pool salt sell replaced-2023; pool pump replaced-2022; new dock pilings and deck-2024; new washer-2020; new dryer-2022; new two-zone lawn sprinkler-2022; carport floor epoxied-2024. Make your appointment today to see this gem.

2771 Teal Court, St James City
2210 Eighth Avenue, St James City
$1,165,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
Oh the joy of waking to sweeping, big water views from your island hideaway! Calm, serene, tranquil. This beautifully renovated 3 bedroom, 3 en-suite bath waterfront pool home offers the perfect escape from city life, while remaining conveniently close to shopping, dining, and mainland access. Set directly on Matlacha Pass, the home features an open floor plan ideal for hosting family gatherings & breezy parties, balanced by separate spaces for privacy & comfort. Enjoy a kitchen designed for entertaining & gourmet meals - ZLINE double oven, glass cooktop, pot-filler, side-by-side refrigerator, two dishwashers and an impressive 11’ quartz center island! A striking marble backsplash is a kitchen focal point. Luxury vinyl plank flooring flows throughout (guest bedroom #2 is tile) – no carpet anywhere - while IMPACT resistant glass surrounds the home, including pocketing sliders in the great room, kitchen & primary suite, seamlessly blending indoor & outdoor living. All bathrooms have been stylishly updated with frameless showers & designer tile. Beyond aesthetics, this home offers peace of mind with 12 foundation stabilization piers, along with a new roof, newer A/C, new ductwork, new insulation, new electric panel & breakers, new underground electric service and meter to the home & tankless water heater. The spacious laundry room includes a Maytag washer & dryer & utility sink. A 2-car garage, modern finishes, & turnkey renovations complete the package. Step outside to your pool surrounded by a travertine deck, native landscaping, & a fully fenced yard for privacy and your furry friends! Boaters will appreciate the covered boat lift rated for 13,500 lbs, along with a wrap-around dock featuring LED lighting, new Ipe wood decking, piling wraps, water, electric, & a fish cleaning station. Kayak enthusiasts will love that the property has access across the street to a tranquil cove with a small launch area. This is an exceptional boating location, offering quick access to Sanibel, Captiva, Useppa, Cabbage Key, Cape Coral, Fort Myers & DIRECT Gulf access for world class offshore fishing. Located in golf-cart friendly Saint James City, the lifestyle here is relaxed, welcoming, and truly a world away from the ordinary. Whether envisioned as a personal retreat or a high-performing rental investment, this property delivers!

2210 Eighth Avenue, St James City
3627 Schooner Lane, St James City
$740,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
Experience the true waterfront living of St. James City in this beautiful 2019 custom waterfront home with 8’+ elevation and quick, easy access to the Gulf, just minutes from the beaches of Sanibel and Captiva, as well as the many restaurants and bars on Ft. Myers Beach. As you approach along the private road, you will appreciate the Key West look of the front with its metal roof and unique stucco finish, corbels, paver driveway leading to an oversized 2-car garage, and irrigated lawn and professional landscaping. Entering through the double glass front doors with plantation shutters, your eyes are immediately drawn through to pocket sliding doors leading to the full-width paver lanai and saltwater pool area with a southern exposure and fully enclosed with no-see-um screens. The office/den is behind frosted French doors and has upgraded wood-look tiles and an octagonal tray ceiling with a fan. From there, the beautiful kitchen boasts 42” cabinets topped with glass-front cabinets and crown molding, a gas range/oven with S/S hood, under counter microwave, new in 2025 - GE refrigerator with two ice makers, a large pantry, maintenance-free quartz countertops, and an oversized island with comfortable seating for four, overlooking the great room with its 10’ ceiling and stunning double trays with custom crown molding and 62” fan. Next to the kitchen is a roomy dining area with lots of natural light. The second full bath has a tub-surround tiled to the ceiling and a custom mirror above a large vanity and access to the pool. Two carpeted guest bedrooms with ceiling fans are conveniently located near the laundry room. On the opposite side of the home and separated from your guests is the tiled primary suite with sliding glass doors opening directly to the pool. The primary bathroom has two walk-in closets behind pocket doors, a beautiful double vanity with custom mirrors, a water closet, and a glassless shower. Outside, the spacious lanai and pool area overlook mangroves, rip-rap, and the 70’ composite dock with a 13,000 lb lift with canopy. There is a 250 gal buried propane tank for the gas stove, tankless water heater, and the pool heater. Hurricane shutters are included, and an electric hurricane screen for the covered lanai area. Additionally, the house is wired for a portable generator with a 50-amp service inlet and has a propane pool heater and tankless water heater. The sellers have a transferable flood that is affordable. The inside of the home has had no damage from flooding. Make your appointment today to see this gorgeous home!

3627 Schooner Lane, St James City
2673 Sanderling Court, St James City
$690,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
This beautiful, direct Gulf-access waterfront pool home in St. James City offers the ideal blend of comfort, convenience, and island charm, sold with all furnishings and household items included. Situated on an oversized cul-de-sac lot, this beautifully updated Key West style home sits high and dry with no flood or wind damage from recent storms, offering peace of mind in paradise. Enjoy breathtaking intersecting canal views from almost every angle of the property. The expansive wrap-around dock includes a 16,000 lb covered PWC boat lift, and easy access to Pine Island Sound and the Gulf of Mexico—perfect for fishing, boating, and cruising to nearby restaurants and beaches. The additional dock/seawall area could be used for jet skis or a second small lift. Downstairs, the screened-in area beneath the home creates a spacious and breezy retreat for entertainment. Host poolside parties, enjoy quiet afternoons with a book, or get creative with a shuffleboard court on the concrete slab. There's ample room for games or activities, maybe yoga by the pool—plus a two-car garage, storage room/shop, and half bath on the lower level. Inside, the upper level features two bedrooms, a den, and two full bathrooms, all in a bright and open layout. The home has been maintained with thoughtful upgrades throughout, including: • Andersen impact windows with plantation shutters • Hardiplank siding • Crown molding • Ralph Lauren designer paint • New AC system + mini split units in the bedrooms to let each guest choose their perfect sleeping temperature • Pool heater and screened pool enclosure • Additional side staircase for easy access Located just a golf cart ride from the heart of St. James City, you’ll love the convenience of local restaurants, waterfront bars, live music, and community events—all while enjoying the quiet charm and Florida lifestyle Pine Island is known for. Whether you're looking for a seasonal getaway, retirement oasis, or full-time residence, this move-in-ready home delivers the ultimate island living experience. Schedule your private showing today—your piece of paradise awaits!

2673 Sanderling Court, St James City
2201 Sanibel Boulevard, Saint James City
$650,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
ALL RENOVATIONS AND UPDATES HAVE BEEN FULLY PERMITTED AND THE PROPERTY REMAINS BELOW THE COUNTY'S 50% IMPROVEMENT THRESHOLD. Beautifully Remodeled Deep Sailboat Waterfront Home – Just Minutes to the Gulf! This stunning 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers direct deep-sailboat access to Redfish Pass and the Gulf of Mexico in just minutes. Nestled at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, the property includes the lot directly across the street—a 0.04-acre waterfront parcel that provides additional water views and the potential to add another dock with a boat lift. Enjoy water views from both the front and rear of your home for a truly one-of-a-kind coastal setting. Inside, an open floor plan welcomes you with a spacious great room, separate dining area, luxury vinyl flooring, and stylish designer light and fan fixtures. The dining area features a built-in buffet with bar and wine refrigerator, while the chef’s kitchen impresses with stainless steel appliances including a gas range, wood cabinetry, pantry, and breakfast bar. Additional highlights include a dedicated laundry area, concrete seawall, and public water service. Countless updates have been made—see the attached Feature Sheet for a complete list of improvements. Perfect for boating and fishing enthusiasts, this property allows you to watch waterfowl and wildlife from your backyard or cast a line right from your own dock for Snook, Grouper, Redfish, and more. This home is a rare find offering the ultimate Florida waterfront lifestyle—schedule your private showing today!

2201 Sanibel Boulevard, Saint James City
2740 Sanibel Boulevard, Saint James City
$635,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
Experience the ultimate Southwest Florida boating lifestyle from this exceptional waterfront home on the quiet Henley Canal. With 136 feet of waterfront, low boat traffic, and no bridges to open water, you'll enjoy approximately 10-minute boat access to Pine Island Sound, world-class fishing, and the white sand beaches of Sanibel Island. The property is perfectly equipped for boating enthusiasts with a covered 10,000 lb boat lift, wraparound dock, and additional davit, making it easy to embrace everything Pine Island has to offer. The home has been thoughtfully upgraded with features that provide both peace of mind and long-term value. The Storm Smart Flood Smart System has been installed, offering an added layer of flood protection by helping prevent water intrusion during flooding events. This innovative system may also contribute to lower homeowners insurance premiums. A transferable flood insurance policy provides additional savings and convenience for the new owner. Major improvements include a new metal roof (2024), new A/C and heating system (2023), hurricane-rated front window and front door, hurricane-rated living room patio door, and hurricane-rated side door, allowing you to enjoy waterfront living with confidence. Inside, the open floor plan is designed to maximize the beautiful canal views, which can be enjoyed from the primary bedroom, guest bedroom, kitchen, living room, and dining area. The beautifully updated kitchen features quartz countertops and new LG appliances (2024), while a cozy fireplace and security system add comfort and convenience. Step outside and experience your own private tropical retreat. The screened pool, approximately five years old, overlooks the canal and is complemented by a spacious 55-foot porch, mature landscaping, and a fenced side yard. A 23 x 12 storage shed provides ample space for tools, hobbies, or a workshop. Nature lovers will appreciate the frequent visits from manatees, ducks, and eagles, all visible from the backyard. When you're ready to explore, you'll enjoy the convenience of nearby restaurants, live music, marinas, and Pine Island events, all accessible by walk, bike, or golf cart. Adding even more versatility, Airbnb rentals are permitted, making this property an excellent opportunity as a primary residence, seasonal getaway, or income-producing investment. This is more than just a waterfront home, it's a chance to enjoy the relaxed island lifestyle with exceptional boating access, modern upgrades, and incredible flexibility in one of Pine Island's most desirable locations.

2740 Sanibel Boulevard, Saint James City
3236 6th Avenue, St James City
$535,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
Welcome home to perfection in this beautifully remodeled two-story stilt residence in Saint James City. Ideally situated on a direct Gulf access canal, this property offers the ultimate boating lifestyle with an 8,000-pound boat lift and just a few minutes ride to the open waters of Pine Island Sound. Explore nearby islands, enjoy some of the best fishing in Florida, or cruise to Fort Myers Beach in only 20 minutes. The day trips from this location are endless and filled with water, fun, sunsets and beaches! Inside, the great room floor plan is designed for both comfort and entertaining. Natural light pours through expansive windows and sliders, highlighting the fluid open space, two bedrooms upstairs modern bathrooms, and a sprawling kitchen island that anchors the space. The home features two private living areas—upstairs and down—perfect for a blended family, guest accommodations, or even a home office setup. The downstairs living quarters include a gorgeous open space with two sliders, a living room, kitchen, and bathroom, offering endless flexibility for guests, extended family, or rental opportunities. Upstairs, the main living area at 13 feet elevation provides peace of mind and showcases bright, airy interiors with seamless access to a screened balcony, ideal for relaxing evenings overlooking the water. Recent updates include a durable metal roof, new windows downstairs, and hurricane-proof enhancements, ensuring both style and security. Outdoors, the expansive driveway and deep backyard offer plenty of room to add a pool, creating your own private oasis. Located in the laid-back island town of Saint James City, you’ll enjoy waterfront dining, local restaurants, and access to the 190-mile Great Calusa Blueway, a marked trail dedicated to kayaking and paddleboarding. A scenic bike path stretches all the way to Bokeelia, adding to the charm of this vibrant community. This home is a rare blend of nostalgic character and modern upgrades, with a fun and flexible floor plan and unbeatable Gulf access—making it the perfect retreat for full-time living or vacation enjoyment.

3236 6th Avenue, St James City
3637 Schooner Lane, St James City
$500,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
This lovely stilt home is perfect for boating enthusiasts, offering an ideal canal location and wonderful outdoor pool space. The property is just a 10-minute boat ride to Pine Island Sound, and within easy walking distance of St. James City's lively restaurant scene. The almost-new screened pool is equipped with electric heat, a fountain, and a chiller for hot summer days. The large surrounding patio opens into an enclosed downstairs area with a bathroom, storage or workshop space, and an air-conditioned entertaining room. Upstairs is an open-concept floorplan with 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom featuring a brand-new shower. The glassed-in porch offers additional living space and scenic views. The kitchen has Corian countertops and there is a brand-new all-in-one washer/dryer. An elevator and brand-new stairs provide easy access to the elevated composite patio and upstairs living area. Boaters and anglers will enjoy the wraparound composite dock with a spacious, covered deck area over the water, as well as a covered boat lift. The boat lift frame is up and the cover is in the shed. New landscaping adds to the home's curb appeal and is virtually maintenance free. Ample parking is available for multiple cars and boats The property includes a metal roof for peace of mind. Lots of potential as a personal retreat or as an income property.

3637 Schooner Lane, St James City
3050 York Road, St James City
$445,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
Boaters, anglers, investors, and island dreamers — this is the one. Welcome to your turnkey waterfront retreat on Monroe Canal in the heart of Saint James City, offering direct boating access with no bridges to the Intracoastal Waterway. Designed for true island living, this property features a 5,000 lb boat lift, a 16,000 lb covered boat lift, and approximately 833 sq. ft. of composite dock/deck space where you can fish, relax, entertain, or launch your next day on the water. This beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath home also includes a bonus bunk room/office, 1,300 sq. ft. under air, a 300 sq. ft. screened lanai with outdoor shower, large patio, and low-maintenance rocked yard. Inside, you’ll find an open layout, porcelain tile throughout, a spacious kitchen with large island, updated cabinetry, stainless appliances, inside laundry, and coastal furnishings that are negotiable, making the home feel bright, clean, and move-in ready. Major updates include plumbing in 2012, renovations in 2015 and 2022, metal roof in 2021, A/C and appliances in 2022, and drain field in 2020. For added peace of mind, the property also includes a custom $68,000 flood barrier system by FloodRisk America, complete with storage trailer. Enjoy waterfront dining, fishing, kayaking, boating, and sunset evenings from your own private dock. Furnishings, select items, and the saltwater hot/cool tub are negotiable separately, perfect for relaxing after a day on the water or cooling off during warm island afternoons.

3050 York Road, St James City
3050 York Road, Saint James City
$445,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
Boaters, anglers, investors, and island dreamers — this is the one. Welcome to your turnkey waterfront retreat on Monroe Canal in the heart of Saint James City, offering direct boating access with no bridges to the Intracoastal Waterway. Designed for true island living, this property features a 5,000 lb boat lift, a 16,000 lb covered boat lift, and approximately 833 sq. ft. of composite dock/deck space where you can fish, relax, entertain, or launch your next day on the water. This beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath home also includes a bonus bunk room/office, 1,300 sq. ft. under air, a 300 sq. ft. screened lanai with outdoor shower, large patio, and low-maintenance rocked yard. Inside, you’ll find an open layout, porcelain tile throughout, a spacious kitchen with large island, updated cabinetry, stainless appliances, inside laundry, and coastal furnishings that are negotiable, making the home feel bright, clean, and move-in ready. Major updates include plumbing in 2012, renovations in 2015 and 2022, metal roof in 2021, A/C and appliances in 2022, and drain field in 2020. For added peace of mind, the property also includes a custom $68,000 flood barrier system by FloodRisk America, complete with storage trailer. Enjoy waterfront dining, fishing, kayaking, boating, and sunset evenings from your own private dock. Furnishings, select items, and the saltwater hot/cool tub are negotiable separately, perfect for relaxing after a day on the water or cooling off during warm island afternoons.

3050 York Road, Saint James City
3659 Schooner Lane, St James City
$440,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
Charming Waterfront Ranch Home with modern upgrades! This beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath ranch-style home on stilts offers the perfect blend of coastal charm and modern convenience. Enjoy breezy open-concept living with an airy layout that invites in the natural light and scenic views. Key features include: new Hardie Plank siding (2020) for lasting durability; brand new A/C unit (2024) to keep you cool all year; water heater replaced in 2023 for peace of mind. Stainless steel appliances in the kitchen including a propane gas stove for the chef in the family. Breakaway walls below add protection and utility. Park your RV with ease — the property includes dedicated RV parking with hookups. Located just minutes away San Carlos Bay and the outer islands, this waterfront gem offers quick boating access and tranquil sunsets. Whether you're seeking a weekend getaway or full-time residence, this home is ready for you to start living the coastal lifestyle.

3659 Schooner Lane, St James City
2892 Sanibel Boulevard, St James City
$433,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
MOTIVATED SELLER - DIRECT GULF ACCESS, NO BRIDGES & NO RENTAL RESTRICTIONS! Welcome to island living in St. James City! This fully renovated waterfront home is an ideal second home, vacation rental investment, or full-time residence, offering direct Gulf access with no bridges, a private dock, and a 6,000-lb boat lift. Located on a peaceful canal, this home puts the Southwest Florida boating lifestyle right outside your door. Cruise to Sanibel, Captiva, Fort Myers Beach, nearby waterfront restaurants, or head out for a day of fishing and sunset rides—all within minutes from your backyard. Inside, the open-concept layout is light, inviting, and filled with beautiful canal views. The updated kitchen features modern cabinetry, granite countertops, a coordinating backsplash, and brand-new appliances on the way. A split-bedroom floor plan offers privacy for guests, while the primary suite includes an updated bathroom with a walk-in shower, spacious closet, and sliding glass doors leading to the screened lanai. Enjoy outdoor living from the screened lanai overlooking the water, or step down to your private dock and boat lift for effortless Gulf access. Additional features include hurricane-impact windows and doors, thoughtful renovations throughout, and true turnkey convenience. With no rental restrictions and a location just a short walk from popular St. James City waterfront restaurants, this home offers outstanding flexibility and island lifestyle appeal. The seller is motivated—schedule your private showing today and start enjoying your own piece of waterfront paradise!

2892 Sanibel Boulevard, St James City
3580 Gondola Lane, St James City
$380,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
Completely renovated, move-in ready waterfront home on Pine Island with direct Gulf access via intersecting canals. This home features a new roof, drywall, upgraded kitchen with breakfast bar, new bathrooms, fixtures, and fans. Enjoy peace of mind with hurricane shutters on all windows. The expansive, air-conditioned sunroom, accessible from the living room and master bedroom, offers panoramic canal views. Freshly painted inside and out, this home feels modern and bright. Located on a quiet dead-end street, it's minutes from the Gulf and includes a functional boat lift, dock, shed, and fruit trees. Embrace island living with boating, kayaking, and fishing right from your backyard.

3580 Gondola Lane, St James City
2543 8th Avenue, St James City
$256,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
Opportunity awaits in the heart of St. James City! This 2-bedroom, 2-bath home offers 1,361 sq ft of living space and is perfectly situated on an oversized .31-acre canal-front lot, an ideal setting for boating enthusiasts and those seeking the laid-back island lifestyle. The home has been taken down to the studs and is ready for your vision and renovation. Whether you’re looking to create a custom primary residence, seasonal retreat, or investment property, this blank slate provides endless potential to design exactly what you want. Enjoy direct canal access with the possibility of adding a dock or lift and take advantage of the generous lot size with room to expand, add outdoor living spaces, or store your toys. Located in a peaceful waterfront community known for fishing, boating, and natural beauty, yet still convenient to local dining, amenities and a short boat ride out to the intracoastal waterway and Gulf of Mexico. Bring your contractor and imagination, this is your chance to transform a canal-front property into your own piece of paradise! Seller Pays: Buyer uses Premium Title Services, the seller’s preferred title partner and closing agent. This lets the buyer bypass the title insurance fee, related search costs and reduced escrow/settlement fees, since the seller will cover those charges. The average charges for title search and insurance is $1225 & escrow/settlement fees is $875, resulting in an overall savings of ~$1660 for buyers, who opt for Premium Title Services. All information recorded in the MLS is intended to be accurate but cannot be guaranteed, buyer advised to verify.

2543 8th Avenue, St James City
2727 Sanderling Court, St James City
$237,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gulfhaven SubDv.
Due to high interested the seller is asking for all offers to be submitted by 8/26/2026 by 12pm. A boaters dream: This home, located at the southern part of St. James City, on Pine Island, Florida, is just perfect for someone looking to create their outdoor adventure getaway. With a new metal roof, this home is perfect for the investor or future homeowner looking to rebuild and create the home of their dreams. With the Gulf of Mexico, boating to Sanibel, Captiva, and the gulf islands less than two miles away, access to restaurants and a vacation paradise awaits. Seller does not remember applying for flood insurance, FEMA assistance. Flood Disclosure is completed as best as possible after consulting with both Florida Realtors Legal Hotline and a Real Estate Attorney. Septic Tank condition is unknown to seller.

2727 Sanderling Court, St James City

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!