St James City Real Estate

St James City Real Estate

Welcome to St. James City, a hidden gem nestled on the serene Pine Island in Lee County, Florida. This quaint community offers a unique blend of natural beauty, coastal charm, and a relaxed lifestyle that attracts both residents and visitors alike.

St. James City is renowned for its stunning waterfront views, making it a paradise for fishing enthusiasts and boaters. With easy access to the Gulf of Mexico, you can spend your days exploring the abundant marine life, indulging in water sports, or simply basking in the sun on the pristine beaches nearby. The area’s lush landscapes and picturesque sunsets create an idyllic backdrop for those seeking tranquility away from the hustle and bustle of city life.

The community is rich in local culture, featuring charming shops, delightful eateries, and friendly neighbors who embody the spirit of small-town living. Whether you’re enjoying fresh seafood at a waterfront restaurant or browsing unique boutiques, St. James City offers a delightful experience at every turn.

Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the numerous parks and nature preserves in the area, where you can hike, bird-watch, or simply enjoy the stunning natural surroundings. St. James City is also conveniently located just a short drive from Fort Myers, giving you easy access to a wider range of amenities, entertainment, and healthcare facilities.

If you’re looking for a peaceful retreat that combines the beauty of nature with a welcoming community spirit, St. James City is the perfect place to call home. Come discover the charm of this coastal paradise and experience the vibrant lifestyle that awaits you!

Newest Listings in St James City

2805 8th Avenue, St James City
$849,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gulf Haven SubDv.
4 BED 2 BA Canal front pool home located on a huge corner lot. The home is ground level above grade so it experienced no water intrusion for our recent hurricanes. The property also has a boathouse with a new metal roof & davits along with a covered boat lift. upgrades include new exterior sherwin william paint--some new lania screening. huge chef's kitchen with center island cooktop--granite counter tops--luxury vinyl plank flooring. storm protected with manual shutters. partially furnished as seen.

2805 8th Avenue, St James City
3023 Skipper Lane, St James City
$325,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cherry Estates SubDv.
Experience the laid-back island lifestyle in beautiful St. James City! Nestled in the waterfront community of Cherry Estates on Pine Island, this furnished 2-bedroom, 2-bath home offers 1,444 square feet of comfortable living space with the perfect blend of relaxation and coastal charm. Step inside to discover a spacious, inviting floor plan featuring a generous great room, an eat-in kitchen, and plenty of room to entertain family and friends. Enjoy peaceful canal views from the enclosed waterfront porch, an ideal spot for morning coffee or unwinding after a day on the water. Boating enthusiasts will love having a private boat lift and direct water access, making it easy to enjoy fishing, cruising, and exploring the beautiful waterways of Southwest Florida. Additional highlights include an indoor laundry room, abundant storage, covered parking, and a patio for enjoying the Florida sunshine. The home has not experienced flooding during previous storms, an especially noteworthy feature for waterfront living. Whether you’re searching for a seasonal escape or a full-time residence, this property offers an opportunity to embrace everything that makes island living so special. Discover the charm of St. James City with its waterfront restaurants, local entertainment, excellent fishing, and relaxed coastal atmosphere. Come experience the waterfront lifestyle and make your island dreams a reality!

3023 Skipper Lane, St James City
4096/4070 Shellcrest Road, St James City
$199,000
St James City SubDv.
YOUR ISLAND HOMESTEAD AWAITS IN ST. JAMES CITY! This 2.73-acre AG-2 parcel is priced to sell and offers the perfect opportunity to create your own private island retreat. Just minutes from boat ramps, waterfront restaurants, and charming St. James City, you’ll enjoy easy access to Pine Island Sound, the Gulf, and beautiful beaches. Plenty of space to park your boats, trailers, RV's and more….. This partially cleared homesite is surrounded by towering pines, palmettos, and tropical landscaping. Build a single-family home, use it for agriculture, or do both. Water and electricity available!! With plenty of room for pets, gardens, and a self-sustaining lifestyle, this peaceful, private acreage offers the space and freedom to bring your island homestead dreams to life!

4096/4070 Shellcrest Road, St James City
3606 Myers Lane, St James City
$32,000
St James City SubDv.
Bring your vision to life on this oversized homesite nestled in the peaceful surroundings of Pine Island! Tucked away on a quiet street, this spacious parcel offers the perfect canvas to create your dream island retreat. Imagine designing your own tropical oasis complete with a sparkling pool, lush landscaping, colorful gardens, and plenty of room to enjoy the outdoor lifestyle. There's ample space for your boats, trailers, and all the toys that make island living so special! Previously cleared and ready for your plans, this property offers a great head start, with existing overgrowth easily cleared to make way for your vision. Enjoy the convenience of level terrain, and a parcel survey is already available. Whether you're dreaming of a full-time residence or a relaxing island getaway, this is your opportunity to secure an affordable piece of Pine Island and create something truly special. Great location, generous homesite, and endless potential! Don't let this opportunity sail away!

3606 Myers Lane, St James City
4958 Mullette Lane, St James City
$35,000
Pine Island Cove SubDv.
This cleared lot in Pine Island Cove 55+ community is located on one of the quieter streets and is very close to the beautiful community lake and recreation area. It's a great place for your retirement home whether you are a seasonal resident or year round. The community offers many amenities including the ever popular pickleball, large community swimming pool, hot tub and community center.

4958 Mullette Lane, St James City
2272 Macadamia Street, St James City
$1,699,995
5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Pine Island Shores Unit 11 SubDv.
**BREATHTAKING BAYFRONT VIEWS, FIVE PRIVATE EN SUITES & EXCEPTIONAL BOATING ACCESS!** Some homes are about the finishes. Others are about a location and a view that simply cannot be recreated. This is one of those homes! Discover an extraordinary opportunity to own a spacious bayfront retreat in St. James City, offering sweeping panoramic views of Pine Island Sound, spectacular sunrises and sunsets, and an ever-changing backdrop of sparkling water and abundant marine life. Boasting over 3,700 square feet of living space and an impressive FIVE PRIVATE EN SUITES, this residence offers exceptional space, comfort and privacy for family, friends and overnight guests. Walls of windows fill the home with natural light while capturing breathtaking waterfront views from multiple vantage points. Step outside to your own tropical oasis featuring a NEW heated saltwater pool, perfectly positioned to enjoy the incredible scenery. A NEW standing seam metal roof adds lasting value, while TWO boat lifts with motors replaced in 2023 provide convenient access to the surrounding waterways. Enjoy quick, deep-water access to Pine Island Sound, the Gulf of Mexico and the beautiful beaches of Sanibel, Captiva, Cayo Costa and Fort Myers Beach. World-class fishing, boating, island hopping and waterfront dining are all part of the lifestyle! Whether you're looking for a spacious island getaway, a gathering place for family and friends, or an opportunity to personalize an extraordinary waterfront property, this home offers something truly special. With FIVE PRIVATE EN SUITES, expansive living areas, outstanding boating amenities and BREATHTAKING BAYFRONT VIEWS, the possibilities are endless. **You can personalize a home, but you simply cannot recreate a location or a view like this!** Listing has virtually staged photos.

2272 Macadamia Street, St James City
3016 Bounty Lane, St James City
$279,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cherry Estates Island SubDv.
Here is a direct access waterfront 2bed 2bath manufactured home. It's huge at 1376 sqft. built in 1979 comes turnkey furnished. Extra large master suite which encompasses the complete width of the home. Large kitchen & dining area and a fullwidth Florida room at the canal end of the home. The insideof the home has never had floodwater intrusion into it. Flood damage to the property has been completed including new A/C unit along with all ductwork ,new washer & dryer and carport replacement where needed. The washer & dryer are located in your ground level workshop. There is also another storage shed for your boating needs. The seawall has been reinforced. The boat & trl under the carport is also available so just bring your overnight bag and enjoy our little piece of paradise.

3016 Bounty Lane, St James City
4921 Cobiac Drive, St James City
$199,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Pine Island Cove SubDv.
BRAND NEW! FULLY FURNISHED! LAKEFRONT LIVING! Why settle for an older home when you can have BRAND-NEW construction, beautiful furnishings, and the Florida waterfront lifestyle you’ve been dreaming of? Welcome to Pine Island Cove, one of St. James City’s most desirable 55+ waterfront communities! This stunning, newly constructed home comes COMPLETELY FURNISHED and ready for you to start enjoying island life from day one! Step inside and discover a light, bright, beautifully appointed interior featuring an inviting open-concept living area, a gorgeous kitchen with white cabinetry and modern appliances, attractive wood-look flooring, and tasteful coastal décor throughout. But the real magic happens outside! Step through your sliding glass doors onto your COVERED WATERFRONT DECK, where peaceful canal views, tropical surroundings, and gentle island breezes create the perfect setting for morning coffee or evening cocktails. And the lifestyle doesn’t stop at your doorstep! Pine Island Cove offers an incredible collection of amenities, including a sparkling COMMUNITY POOL and SPA, PICKLEBALL and BOCCE BALL COURTS, a spacious clubhouse, a community pavilion, dog park, and lake! BOATING ENTHUSIASTS will love the community’s PRIVATE BOAT RAMP providing access to Pine Island Sound and the Gulf, plus convenient additional boat and trailer storage. Spend your days fishing, boating to nearby barrier islands, relaxing by the pool, or exploring the unique shops, waterfront restaurants, and laid-back charm of Pine Island. With a low HOA of $160 a month you can't beat the value. Own your own land make your own memories at 4921 Cobiac!

4921 Cobiac Drive, St James City
2561 York Road, St James City
$359,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Trailerhaven SubDv.
DIRECT GULF ACCESS – NO BRIDGES – APPROXIMATELY 5 MINUTES TO OPEN WATER! Welcome to your own slice of island paradise in desirable St. James City! This beautifully renovated 2-bedroom, 2-bath waterfront home offers the perfect blend of coastal charm, modern updates, and laid-back Florida living. Step inside to discover tile flooring throughout and an updated kitchen featuring granite countertops, a center island, and a stylish tile backsplash. Additional upgrades include an on-demand hot water heater and newer mini-split A/C systems. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the impressive waterfront setup featuring a 10,000-pound covered boat lift with remote-controlled motors, limit switch, updated motors and bunks (2023), automatic underwater green light, and low-maintenance Trex decking. Major improvements include a NEW ROOF (2024) and NEW CARPORT (2024)! Enjoy your morning coffee or evening cocktails on the spacious screened lanai while soaking in the peaceful island atmosphere. A separate laundry room and dedicated workshop provide additional convenience and space for hobbies, projects, and storage. Step outside into your own tropical oasis featuring a fully fenced yard with 18 established fruit and avocado trees! Additional features include perimeter security lighting and three video surveillance cameras. Whether you’re searching for a full-time residence, seasonal escape, or weekend boating retreat, this waterfront gem checks all the boxes. Bring your boat and start enjoying the St. James City lifestyle, where open water and endless adventures are just minutes away!

2561 York Road, St James City
2900 Binnacle Lane, St James City
$320,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cherry Estates Rv Park SubDv.
GULF ACCESS, DEEDED WATERFRONT LAND & EXTENSIVE UPDATES IN CHERRY ESTATES! Welcome to relaxed island living at 2900 Binnacle Lane in St. James City, where your own canal-front retreat puts Southwest Florida's boating, fishing & waterfront lifestyle within easy reach. Situated on an individually owned lot with NO LOT RENT, this inviting home offers an exceptional opportunity for a seasonal escape, full-time residence or weekend getaway. Step inside to discover a bright, comfortable interior with updated flooring, decorative trim, refreshed finishes, updated light fixtures & ceiling fans. The open living & dining areas offer plenty of space to gather, while windows & sliding glass doors bring in natural light and draw your eye toward the water. The beautifully remodeled kitchen is a standout, featuring crisp white cabinetry, Corian countertops, stainless steel appliances, a modern range hood & a generous breakfast bar that adds preparation space and casual seating. Both bedrooms offer comfortable retreats, while the bathrooms feature updated vanities and finishes. The improvements extend well beyond the kitchen! The seller reports a new roof, newer siding with added insulation and foam board, updated skirting, insulation beneath the replacement flooring & a hurricane-rated sliding glass door. Electrical improvements have been completed along the kitchen/main-entrance side and in the laundry area. The A/C and water heater are approximately five years old, with A/C tubing replaced following Hurricane Ian. These improvements complement the home's welcoming coastal feel while offering buyers a head start on many major updates. Outside is where the island lifestyle really shines! Open the sliding doors to a spacious tiled patio overlooking the canal, framed by tropical palms and perfect for morning coffee, outdoor dining or unwinding after a day on the water. The property features a seawall, fish-cleaning station & boat lift, offering an appealing waterfront setup for boating enthusiasts and anglers. The boat lift previously operated but currently requires electrical repairs. Two storage sheds provide additional room for fishing tackle, tools, boating gear & seasonal equipment. Select furnishings may also be available with the sale, subject to agreement. Cherry Estates offers a network of canals with boating access to the Gulf of America, putting the waterways and natural beauty of Pine Island at your doorstep. Enjoy nearby waterfront dining, excellent fishing opportunities, island shops & a slower pace of life, all without the ongoing expense of leased land. Whether you're seeking a place to launch your next adventure or simply relax by the water, this property combines extensive improvements, a desirable canal setting, valuable waterfront amenities & remarkably low annual association dues. Come experience the possibilities of waterfront living in St. James City!

2900 Binnacle Lane, St James City
3548 Jade Avenue, St James City
$1,299,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Bayview Acres SubDv.
Experience exceptional waterfront living in St. James City, where a prime tip-lot location w/ 183 feet of seawall, expansive intersecting canal views & outstanding boating amenities create the ultimate Southwest Florida island retreat! Meticulously maintained & thoughtfully updated, this residence offers a straight shot to the Intracoastal Waterway, providing quick, direct, no-bridge access to Pine Island Sound, the Gulf, world-class fishing & beautiful beaches of Sanibel, Captiva, Cayo Costa & Fort Myers Beach. Adding exceptional value is assumable flood insurance under $600 annually, subject to carrier approval. A boater's paradise featuring 12K & 8K boat lifts, a covered boathouse, composite docks, jet ski lifts, dockside water & electric & seawall new in 2007. Tropical landscaping creates privacy & seclusion, while the fenced & gated entrance adds exclusivity. The ground level is a resort-style oasis featuring an electrically heated saltwater pool & spa, firepit area, outdoor shower & expansive covered outdoor living spaces w/ dining & lounge areas, perfect for entertaining after a day on the water. Additional features include utility & storage space, covered parking for 2–3 vehicles, an RV pad w/ 30-amp service, whole-house generator & propane tanks. The main living level is light, bright & designed to capture waterfront views from nearly every angle. Expansive windows fill the open-concept great room w/ natural light, flowing seamlessly into the remodeled kitchen featuring granite countertops, quartz center island, glass tile backsplash, black stainless steel appliances, gas double oven & walk-in pantry. Sliders open to wraparound decks along the rear & side of the residence, blending indoor & outdoor living while showcasing spectacular water views. Two guest bedrooms, one w/ sliders to the deck, & a guest bathroom complete this level. The entire upper level is dedicated to a private primary suite featuring soaring vaulted ceilings, a generous bedroom, walk-in closet & en suite bath w/ dual-sink vanity & walk-in shower w/ multiple showerheads. Step onto your private waterfront deck to enjoy coastal breezes & beautiful water views. Crowning this residence is a rooftop terrace offering breathtaking panoramic views stretching for miles across the Intracoastal Waterway toward Sanibel & Fort Myers, an extraordinary setting for enjoying sunsets & the beauty of Southwest Florida. Updates & features include a new metal roof (2023), fresh exterior paint (2026), Hardie board siding, impact-resistant windows, sliders & entry doors, two elevated A/C systems & a mini-split. With exceptional boating facilities, direct Gulf access & a beautifully maintained residence designed for indoor-outdoor living, this property embodies the luxury island lifestyle. Spend your days cruising the islands, fishing the Gulf waters, exploring secluded beaches or relaxing in your own waterfront paradise. This is St. James City living at its finest!

3548 Jade Avenue, St James City
4018 Stringfellow Road, St James City
$275,000
St James City SubDv.
Discover the possibilities on Pine Island! Situated on over 7 acres in St. James City, this expansive property features more than 4 acres of uplands and over 500 feet of frontage on a freshwater canal. A 300-foot-deep artesian well and electricity already in place add to its appeal. Imagine creating your own island retreat with room to enjoy the natural surroundings and relaxed pace of island life. Explore Pine Island’s local restaurants, art galleries, and opportunities for fishing, boating, and kayaking. Access is provided by a recorded perpetual ingress and egress easement from Laratonda Road. A wonderful opportunity to bring your vision to life in Southwest Florida! Buyer to verify allowable uses, environmental requirements, and permitting.

4018 Stringfellow Road, St James City
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!