Refine Search
Sort by
11859 Island Avenue, Matlacha
$1,925,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Matlacha SubDv.
This stunning custom-built home offers DIRECT ACCESS to the Gulf of Mexico and boasts expansive water views that are sure to impress. BUILT IN 2020, this property features multiple balconies, decks, and rooms designed to capture Matlacha's serene coastal vibe. Situated on direct Gulf access with no bridges to slow you down, the home includes a new SEAWALL with a TREX DOCK and a COVERED 10,000lb BOAT LIFT, providing convenient storage and protection, all right in your own backyard. Upon entering through the leaded glass doors, you will be greeted by the warmth of sunlight reflecting off the stunning custom-designed epoxy flooring that flows throughout the main floor. The main floor features a divided primary bedroom with an en-suite and access to the PRIVATE ORCHID BALCONY. ThIS west facing primary offers access to the pool deck and the screened lanai which features ELECTRIC ROLL DOWN SHADES for easy sun control. The MAIN FLOOR also includes a laundry area, open concept kitchen, dining, and living areas. The spacious Chef's Kitchen features beautiful maintenance-free CAMBRIA QUARTZ countertops and top-of-the-line BLACK STEEL appliances. Family and guests can enjoy socializing with the cook while seated at the EXPANSIVE serving island before heading to the lanai to enjoy the relaxing wide water views of Matlacha Pass. UPSTAIRS, a spacious family room awaits, accessible by a PRIVATE ELEVATOR. The second floor includes a primary bedroom with an en-suite and a sitting area. There is also a second-floor laundry, a bonus area, observation deck, a family room with kitchen facilities, and a screened porch also outfitted with electric roll-down shades. There are two additional bedrooms, one with an en-suite and the other bedroom with easy access to the screened balcony at the front of the house. It's always fun to watch the boats head out Matlacha Pass while enjoying your morning coffee and watching the sunrise! The ground floor features a three-car garage/workshop designed to function seamlessly in the event of severe weather. All important elements such as A/C, electric, and plumbing are raised high along block walls to avoid impact from severe weather. Notably, the house colors pay homage to the University of Minnesota, featuring the Maroon and Gold colors associated with their beloved Mascot, GOLDY GOPHER. For those who prefer a more understated color palette, Chat GPT offers some alternative options cleary marked as AI Enhanced. This property offers a one-of-a-kind Matlacha living experience, combining luxury, convenience, and coastal charm in a picturesque waterfront setting.

11859 Island Avenue, Matlacha

4574 Pine Island Road NW, Matlacha
$1,340,000
Position your business at Matlacha’s most visible corner location! This fully remodeled commercial property at 4574 Pine Island Rd NW is currently operated as a real estate office and offers exceptional exposure plus two access points for smooth ingress/egress—ideal for trucks, service vehicles, and client traffic. Recent upgrades include a NEW roof, new flooring, and impact-rated hurricane doors and windows for peace of mind. The interior is light, bright, and inviting, creating a professional atmosphere for clients and staff. An ADA-accessible ramp enhances usability and compliance. Fantastic opportunity for a real estate office, professional services, medical office, retail showroom, or boutique business looking for maximum visibility at the gateway to Matlacha/Pine Island. Extensive parking and NEVER flooded! Traffic Count (16,100 AADT (average annual daily trips/vehicles per day) along the Pine Island Road corridor near Matlacha.

4574 Pine Island Road NW, Matlacha

2859 Cheryl Street, Matlacha
$599,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Matlacha SubDv.
Rare waterfront opportunity in the heart of iconic Matlacha, offering a true multi-generational floor plan with a full mother-in-law suite, all situated on two spacious lots with exceptional features throughout. With 128 feet of waterfront and direct Gulf access, the property includes a 7,000 lb covered boat lift with fish-cleaning station and a 2017 saltwater solar-heated pool with tanning ledge. The home provides two distinct living spaces—a 2-bedroom, 1-bath unit and a 1-bedroom, 1-bath mother-in-law suite—connected by a double-keyed interior door while still offering private exterior entrances, paved driveways, and covered parking. Interior features include two full kitchens with upgraded appliances and modern countertops, impact-resistant windows and doors, a shared enclosed lanai and pool area with individual sliding-door access, a common laundry room, and a large storage room. The home enjoys desirable southern exposure on the pool side, offering excellent natural light throughout the day. Outdoor highlights include a fully fenced yard with double gate, an RV-ready side yard with electrical hookups, and a 2020 roof. Beautiful canal views are preserved from both units, enhancing the appeal of both living spaces. *Transferable Flood Insurance Policy This property also offers outstanding rental flexibility and strong investment potential. The 1-bedroom suite is ideal for annual rentals, short-term rentals, or Airbnb, and both units can be rented separately for maximum income. The layout is perfectly suited for multi-generational living or conversion to a single-family home with a private mother-in-law suite. Just minutes from your boat lift to Matlacha Pass, this exceptionally maintained property provides unmatched access to world-class fishing, boating, and the vibrant island lifestyle.

2859 Cheryl Street, Matlacha

2701 Bruce Street, Matlacha
$580,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Matlacha SubDv.
PRICE REDUCTION!!Perfect Opportunity to Customize a Well Built Matlacha Home! This home sits on 100ft of deep-water Gulf access and is the second home from Matlacha Pass which provides open water views! Matlacha is a waterman’s paradise surrounded by world class fishing, pristine beaches, abundant native wildlife and offers access to the Great Calusa Blueway Kayak Trail. Everything Matlacha has to offer, including restaurants and shops, is just a short walk or bike ride away. This open floor plan 3-bedroom 2 bath home is ready for you to personalize but is loaded with tons of upgrades to build upon! As soon as you walk into the home you are met with a panoramic water view through the 20ft of impact sliding doors that line the back of the expansive great room area which is the central hub of the home. There are impact windows and doors throughout this home. The large open kitchen is ready for you to customize and also offers views of the canal and Matlacha Pass. The master suite offers a water view and features a walk-in closet and an oversize jacuzzi. Your guests will be spoiled when they visit with the spa like guest bath that features a Koehler steam shower! The steam shower has beautiful tile work, glass doors as well as a natural green beach pebble floor. The interior of this home includes a large laundry area and a finished garage that the owner used for a recording studio. They always say they don’t build them like they used to and that definitely applies to this home! The roof structure is over-built with plank construction instead of plywood which makes it incredibly strong. A new water barrier and tile roof was installed in 2014 offering many years of roof life (Typical tile roof life is 40-50 years). Third nail was installed to help with insurance discounts as well. The roof has weathered multiple storms with no issues. The outside spaces of this home really make it something special! The screened pool area is the perfect place to take in the beauty of Matlacha, including breath taking sunrises and sunsets or dolphins and manatees that cruise by daily. The pool has been renovated with new tiles, a pebbletech surface and is a heated saltwater system. The pool enclosure has also been updated and features a travertine pool deck. The almost 900 sqft dock is a fisherman’s dream featuring a dual cable 10k covered boat lift complete with remote (cover is currently being stored in the shed). The property itself features lush tropical landscaping including your own mango tree, a custom fence for privacy, a Tuff shed for extra storage and black river stone accents throughout. As a HUGE bonus a Generac Generator has been installed with a 600-gallon propane tank. Home features 2 AC systems as well, one for the main home and one for the finished garage (currently detached). Make sure to view the drone link to see the stunning surroundings of this home! Now is the time to get into Matlacha....Come see this home today and start Living the Island Life!

2701 Bruce Street, Matlacha

2480 Bayshore Drive, Matlacha
$570,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Island Harbors SubDv.
Experience the best of the Southwest Florida lifestyle in this luxuriously upgraded waterfront island home THAT IS ELEVATED -never flooded- WITH BAY VIEWS! Perfectly blending modern choices with a breezy coastal farmhouse aesthetic, found in the heart of artsy Matlacha. Nearly every room inside offers stunning views of Matlacha Pass and sunrise over the iconic Matlacha Bridge! The interior’s light-filled spaces flow seamlessly from the REMODELED KITCHEN (with high capacity refrigerator) to the large lanai and pool deck, down to the NEW DOCK AND LIFT (2023). After a hard day of fishing retreat to the massive master suite, while guests enjoy the privacy of the split-bedroom layout, with their own sliding glass door to the lanai. The large backyard features a fire pit and unparalleled views of the water, where you can watch as dolphins and manatees play just feet from your seawall. Built in 1990, this home has NEVER FLOODED thanks to the ELEVATED LOT at 7.9 feet high (elevation certificate available in MLS). Offering maximum protection via a METAL ROOF, IMPACT WINDOWS AND 3 IMPACT RATED DOORS, the property provides significant insurance premium savings and lower cooling costs. Take a short walk to local art galleries, the coffee shop, seafood restaurants, and the community park from this cul-de-sac with amazing views. This "piece of paradise" is a rare opportunity to own a move-in-ready, storm-resilient home in one of Florida's most beloved coastal communities. We have all the reports, the survey, the home layout, just ask. The seller has no intention of letting this listing sit on the market. If this is the one for you make your move. Schedule your private showing in person or by video call today!

2480 Bayshore Drive, Matlacha

2504 Bayshore Drive, Matlacha
$505,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Island Harbors SubDv.
Back on the market at no fault to the seller. Beautiful Bay Front Opportunity: This wildlife-rich retreat features a modern island kitchen with new stainless appliances, and updates throughout the interior. 30 year Roof added in 2019. Dock and boat lifts added in 2020. Low assumable insurance. Frequent dolphin sightings from the expansive paver patio, with mature tropical fruit trees & an outdoor shower. This is direct Gulf access (no bridges or locks from the island) with two 10,000-lb boat lifts and davit for your oversized crabbing pot or fishing kayak. Perfect for RV & trailer owners. Great investment potential. Not in the historic district! No HOA. Transferable Flood Insurance only $4000/yr. Ideal for a primary residence, vacation home, or income-producing Airbnb. **ASK ABOUT ACQUIRING PROPERTY NEXTDOOR IF YOU ARE INTERESTED IN BUILDING! Don't miss out on this one, at this price it will be gone soon! Check out the Virtual Tour for another look at this waterfront gem.

2504 Bayshore Drive, Matlacha

4760 Pine Island Road NW, Matlacha
$480,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Matlacha SubDv.
**ACCEPTING BACK-UP OFFERS**Here is your chance to own a slice of waterfront paradise in the historic area of Matlacha! This property consists of two cottages, "Pink" and "Green" and they each offer two units within each cottage making the opportunities endless!! You could live and work out of one cottage and rent out the other cottage as one or two units. Zoned C1 so smaller scale commercial uses may also be an option. Both cottages have been completely remodeled with no detail spared and are immaculate. Both cottages offer a full kitchen, two bathrooms, impact resistant doors, impact resistant windows, luxury laminate flooring throughout, washer & dryer and their own patio. Carport has two separate storage closets. From your own back yard you can fish, kayak, boat the amazing bay areas to some of the most sought after islands, catch breathtaking sunrises and sunsets, endless wildlife watching and so much more. All of this and you are located in the heart of Matlacha where you can walk to small retail shops and top rated restaurants.

4760 Pine Island Road NW, Matlacha

2781 Bruce Street, Matlacha
$445,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Island Harbors SubDv.
Waterfront Paradise with Direct Gulf Access and SOUTHERN EXPOSURE! Experience the ultimate Florida lifestyle at 2781 Bruce Street. This beautifully and luxuriously updated home features TWO spacious primary suites, 3-bathroons with a sunroom and offers effortless indoor-outdoor living and PRIME Gulf-access boating with deep water access and one minute out to open waters. Fully renovated kitchen and bathrooms with modern finishes, complimented by plantation shutters throughout, combining elegance and functionality. Wake up to serene canal views, enjoy morning coffee in the sunroom flooded with natural light, and step outside to your private dock with boat lift —and an open, airy layout with large windows frames the sparkling canal and enhances the bright, welcoming interior. This home is being sold fully furnished, making it move-in ready and perfect for immediate enjoyment. Designed for those who crave both relaxation and adventure, it’s ideal for entertaining, unwinding by the water, or launching your boat directly to the Gulf in minutes. Located in a tranquil residential setting in the magical island of Matlacha and filled with olde Florida charm, stunning sunsets, with some of the best fishing right off your back yard! Stroll over to the many shops/artist galleries just a few streets away, or enjoy the close to local amenities, this property is perfect for boating enthusiasts, sunseekers, and anyone dreaming of a true waterfront escape. This is more than a home — it’s a lifestyle. Your waterfront paradise awaits!

2781 Bruce Street, Matlacha

11828 Island Avenue, Matlacha
$375,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Matlacha SubDv.
Waterfront living at its best in the HISTORIC VILLAGE OF MATLACHA! This fully turnkey, 2-bedroom, 2-bath home features a 1 car garage, NEWER SHINGLE ROOF, IMPACT WINDOWS and DOORS and offers DIRECT GULF ACCESS with NO BRIDGES, allowing boaters to reach open water in under 10 minutes. The property includes a SEAWALL and COVERED 8,000 lb BOAT LIFT + DOCK making it ideal for boating and fishing enthusiasts. Recent upgrades include FULL REPLUMBLING, NEW AC, and a NEW WATER HEATER—all completed with proper permitting for added peace of mind. Inside, the home offers a functional layout with lots of natural sunlight, renovated kitchen, QUARTZ COUNTERTOPS, WHITE SHAKER STYLE CABINETS, and stainless steel/black appliance package. Additionally, there is an in-residence laundry with washer and dryer included. Enjoy the outdoors from the enclosed lanai and appreciate the added privacy of the semi-fenced yard with plenty of front and backyard on a quiet road! Please note: the home has been virtually staged. Furnishings and décor shown in photos are for illustrative purposes only and may not reflect items present during in-person showings. The property itself is move-in ready and offers an exceptional opportunity to enjoy the Matlacha waterfront lifestyle. This home is priced to sell--Schedule Your Showing Today!

11828 Island Avenue, Matlacha

2634 Coco Plum Drive, Matlacha
$292,400
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Matlacha SubDv.
REDUCED $25K! NO FLOODING from any previous hurricanes! **OWNER financing available** This ELEVATED Gulf-Access home built in 2018 is a proven TURNKEY furnished short-term rental with 200+ Airbnb reviews rated 4.99 stars. ~$20,000+ in Rental Income so far in 2026! Enjoy wide water views, a large floating dock with shade and seating, and room to park your boat or install a dock & lift. Inside, you’ll find 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, vaulted ceilings, stainless steel appliances, and stylish updates throughout. Located in the heart of Matlacha, you’re steps from popular restaurants and shops, with easy access to the ferry to Boca Grande, Cayo Costa, Captiva & more. The Great Calusa Blueway Kayak Trail (200 miles) and endless boating, fishing, and kayaking adventures are right at your doorstep. This is one of Matlacha’s most desirable homes — schedule your showing today!

2634 Coco Plum Drive, Matlacha

2595 Pine Street, Matlacha
$254,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Gearys Addn To Matlacha SubDv.
You have to see this unique opportunity! WITH TRANSFERABLE FLOOD INSURANCE!! This versatile property offers the perfect setup for a variety of lifestyles: downstairs, you’ll find a spacious 1-bedroom, 1-bath layout with a dedicated living, dining, and kitchen area. Upstairs, a separate studio apartment provides ideal accommodations for multi-generational living, investors who want to live in one unit and rent out the other, or roommates who value privacy. Features you’ll love: Andersen windows with new slider, quality upgrades installed after Ian repairs. A new metal roof, not just a replacement—an upgrade for durability and style. A tankless water heater to enjoy endless hot water and energy efficiency. And not to mention the Green Board drywall it’s resilient material that dries out easily - peace of mind for island living. Enjoy the fresh, modern space to cook and entertain. While the home doesn’t include storm barriers, consider adding them—these customizable systems work like storm shutters but offers additional protection from storms - invaluable feature for island life. And the best part? You’ll have direct access to the Gulf of America—live the waterfront lifestyle you’ve always dreamed of!

2595 Pine Street, Matlacha

2596 Bayshore Drive, Matlacha
$190,000
Matlacha SubDv.
Prime Direct Gulf Access Lot – with Private Dock & Lift! Offering fast Gulf access with no bridges or locks to slow you down, this property is perfectly situated for those seeking a premium Southwest Florida waterfront lifestyle. Features a high-quality composite dock and a 7,000 lb boat lift on a cleared, buildable lot for a single family home. Located on a 90 foot wide canal, with an average 4 foot depth, making it an ideal location for larger vessels. Shore power tower hook up on dock is a legacy feature, it provides a seamless starting point for a buyer to integrate a state-of-the-art marine power system. City water and sewer available on site. Existing well on the property for irrigation or external use. Not in a historic district or HOA! Come see this prime location. Experience the charm of Matlacha, one of Florida's top fishing communities and a hidden gem for coastal living near Cape Coral and Fort Myers!

2596 Bayshore Drive, Matlacha

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!